Real Name: William Thomas Zeigler
Location: Winter Garden, Florida
Date: December 24, 1975
Details: Tommy Zeigler was accused of four murders in a shoot-out at his furniture and appliance store, those of his wife Eunice, her parents Perry and Virginia Edwards, and a customer, Charlie Mays, which occurred on Christmas Eve in 1975. He was subsequently convicted of the quadruple murder and put on death row. Zeigler, however, believes that a key witness lied on the stand to implicate him, and that he was further railroaded by the police and the court system in a hurry to close the case.
Suspects: None known
Extra Notes: Ths segment was aired in the January 31, 1997 episode.
Results: Unsolved. In 2010, Zeigler was awarded new DNA testing, but this decision was reversed. In February 2013, the Florida Supreme Court again denied Zeigler's motion for DNA testing.