Real Name: Tom Kueter
Nicknames: No known nicknames
Location: Rapid City, South Dakota
Date: June 24, 1994
Details: Shortly after midnight on Friday, June 24, 1994, Tina Marcotte, a late shift worker at Black Hills Molding, a wood processing plant, called Vicky Riddle, her best friend, complaining of a flat tire and asking to be picked up. She noticed a car driving up, and, a short time later, told Vicky she didn't have to come as Tom Kueter, a forklift driver who also worked for Black Hills Molding, was giving her a ride. It was the last time she was heard from. The next morning, Tom and Patrick Gleason, her live-in boyfriend of 11 years, visited Vicky. According to her, Tom became defensive when she mentioned Tina's phone call but finally admitted he was the only Tom who had worked for Black Hills Molding that she would know about. When Patrick asked him if he and Tina were cheating on him, he found his passive denial to be strangely uncharacteristic of him. He suggested that they go together to report her disappearance.
When police examined Tina's car, they discovered that her flat tire had most likely been slashed with a knife, suggesting foul play. Tom was asked to come in for questioning, which he did so voluntarily. During questioning, he denied giving her a ride and said that he had spent his evening at a softball game, taking a friend home, and fixing his car under a streetlight for 3 or 4 hours after it broke down. He pointed to the place where it did so on a map, but police could find no one in that area to confirm his story. He had not called his wife, Nancy, to tell her about his delay that evening. According to her, when he finally arrived home around 3:30am, he immediately began washing his clothes, including his softball uniform and shoelaces. Three days after Tina's disappearance, police came to him at work and told him they had found blood in his car. Around 9am the next morning, just after the shift change, workers found his body with his head crushed by a rear wheel of his own forklift. An investigation by the police led them to believe that he loaded it with at least a ton of lumber, drove it up an incline, hopped out, and laid down in front of its path, taking his own life in a way that seemed accidental, hoping that his family would benefit from it. However, Nancy believes he was murdered, saying he would not leave her and their children alone.
Suspects: Tom was the prime suspect in Tina's murder, though he was never formally linked with it.
Extra Notes: This case first aired on the January 5, 1996 episode.
Results: Solved. Nancy was eventually able to get insurance benefits after a judge ruled that there was not enough evidence to prove that Tom committed suicide. In October 1996, Tina's body was found beneath a wood pile in the lumberyard of Forest Products Distributors, the company Tom worked for at the time of her disappearance and his death. It's believed that her body was deposited there after she was killed. The cause of her death was blunt force trauma. In 2016, authorities closed Tom and Tinas' cases, ruling that Tom was responsible for Tina's death, and that he committed suicide afterwards.