Real Name: Evonne (last name unrevealed)
Case: Lost Sister
Details: Joyce McKelvie had five children, some with her husband, but soon left him because he had a violent temper. She later had a child with another man, but eventually got back with her husband, who forced her to give that child up for adoption because he didn't want to raise one that wasn't his own. He became abusive again, and she again left him. Then, while she was hosting a Christmas party in 1965, he stabbed her to death. Sheryl Borkowski, one of her children, is now searching for her half-sister, Evonne, that was given up for adoption.
Extra Notes: This case first aired on the November 17, 1995 episode.