Real Name: Sherry Melissa Eyerly
Nicknames: No known nicknames
Location: Salem, Oregon
Date: July 4, 1982
Details: Eighteen-year-old Sherry Eyerly vanished on July 4, 1982 while delivering pizzas for Domino's to Riverhaven Drive near Brown Island Road. Her destination was a non-existent address near the Williamette River. Her Ford Pinto was discovered with the engine idling and a pizza on the ground that her attacker stepped on. After over twenty years, her body has yet to be recovered.
Extra Notes: This case first aired on the November 10, 1991 episode. It was also profile on On the case with Paula Zahn.
Results: Solved. Police eventually linked Sherry's abduction to serial killer William Scott Smith who was already in jail for two other attacks. Confessing that he had planned the abduction, he claimed he had dumped her body in the same area of two other victims, but because of flooding in the area, it may never be found.
- Plea Deal Resolves 25-Year-Old Murder Mystery
- Sherry's case on The Charley Project
- William Scott Smith at Murderpedia