Real Name: Milly McGregor
Nicknames: No known nicknames
Location: Cisco Grove, California
Date: September 1995
Date of Birth: Unrevealed
Marital Status: Married
Details: During Labor Day weekend in 1995, sixty-three-year-old Milly McGregor went on a hike alone in the Sierra Nevadas in Northern California. During her hike, she apparently took a wrong turn and got lost. Later in the afternoon, it was noticed she was not home yet. The next morning, a search party began looking for her. Helicopters with infrared technology scanned the mountains for any trace of her. However, after two days, authorities feared that she would not be found alive.
Extra Notes: The case was featured as a part of the May 17, 1996 episode. The case was already solved prior to the broadcast; it focused primarily on the psychic vision.
Results: Solved. Two days after she vanished, a cowboy named Randy Spears learned about Milly's disappearance. He reported that he had a psychic vision telling him where Milly was. In the vision, he saw the silhouette of Sierra Peak, about fifty miles from his ranch. He was certain that he would find her on the mountain's southern slope.
Sometime after midnight, Randy left with his friend Frank Smith and the two drove to the mountains. During the drive, he pointed out a specific spot where he believed Milly was located. The next morning, he and Frank went to the search command center. They convinced others to follow them to the specific area on the mountain. Forty-five minutes of riding took them about three miles from the command center. Randy and Frank separated to cover more ground. Within minutes, he found Milly on a mountain, exhausted but alive.
Milly explained that her heart medication had caused her problems and made it difficult for her to find her way back to safety. She was overjoyed to see Randy and know that she would finally be rescued. A few minutes later, Randy, Frank, and Milly returned to the command center. She was then reunited with her family.
Milly believes that God answered her prayers through Randy Spears.