Real Name: Lisa Ziegert
Nicknames: No Known Nicknames
Location: Agawam, Massachusetts
Date: April 15, 1992
Details: Lisa Ziegert was a beloved teacher in Agawam, Massachusetts who taught special needs students at a local middle school. She disappeared from the gift shop she worked at on April 15, 1992, after talking with her sister there. The next morning, a coworker found the shop unattended and called the police. They found signs of a struggle and blood in the back storage room, and a search soon began. On Easter, her body was found in a wooded area on the edge of town; she had been sexually assualted and stabbed to death. Since she was so well loved, nobody could understand why she was murdered. Thousands stood in the pouring rain at her wake to mourn her death. Authorities soon received three tips in the case. One came from a woman who was at the shop at 8:20pm and found nothing unusual. The second was from a woman who came at 9pm and found the shop open but appearing empty (when in fact, Lisa and her killer(s) were in the back room). The final tip involved a woman who had seen a car with a man and a woman struggling in the backseat around 9:15pm. To this day, Lisa's murder remains unsolved.
Suspects: The car described by the woman was a late model, full sized Bronco or Blazer, either dark red or dark blue. It has never been found.
Extra Notes: This case first aired on the October 27, 1993 episode.