Real Name: Kelly Finnegan
Aliases: Robbi Golden, Kathleen Bennett, Kathy Marie Bruan, Jamie Stewart
Wanted For: Robbery, Burglary, Theft, Poisoning
Missing Since: November 1993
Details: Kelly Finnegan is wanted for drugging and robbing several businessman between March and November 1993. Two of the men that fell prey to her were Giants umpire Terry Tata, and businessman Prem Kumar, who was interviewed in the segment. He was approached by Kelly on November 1, 1993, at a bar of a hotel. He invited her to dinner at Prem's hotel room, and while Prem was shaving, Kelly put a tranquilizer in his drink. After he drank the tranquilizer, and then passed out. When he woke up, she had robbed all of his possesions. When Prem called the police, they recognized the M.O. as Kelly's, and realized that she had been doing these robberies in Nevada, Arizona, Washington, and California. It is unknown how many people she has victimized, probably because married men would be afraid to come forward.
Extra Notes: The case was featured as a part of the May 4, 1994 episode.
Results: Captured. In 1996, Kelly was arrested after a sheriff recognized her from a rerun of Unsolved Mysteries. However, a judge later dismissed the charges against her.