• Jeremy Bright
  • Age Progression (age 40)

Real Name: Jeremy Doland Bright
Nicknames: No Known Nicknames
Location: Myrtle Point, Oregon
Date: August 14, 1986


Occupation: Student
Date of Birth: May 25, 1972
Height: 6'0"
Weight: 140 pounds
Marital Status: Unrevealed
Characteristics: Caucasian male. Brown hair, green eyes. He has a mole on his chin and scars on his forehead and nose.


Details: Fourteen-year-old Jeremy Bright was a popular, sports-loving teenager who looked forward to starting high school in the fall in Grants Pass, Oregon. In August of 1986, the Coos County Fair came to Myrtle Point, Oregon. Jeremy and his sister came to Myrtle Point to attend the fair; they stayed with their stepfather Olie while there. On Thursday, August 14th, Jeremy called his mother, telling her that he was headed to the fair at around 4:45 pm. He supposedly went with his younger sister and a close friend, Johnny Fish (possible real name Gray). Several witnesses saw Johnny and Jeremy together at the fair. Five hours later, at 9:40 pm, Jeremy went to a local tavern, owned by his grandmother, to meet Olie who had just finished work. Olie gave him a few dollars and Jeremy left; this was the last time he was ever seen.
Two days later, Jeremy's mother Diane arrived in Myrtle Point to pick up Jeremy and his sister. However, Jeremy was not home; he had left his wallet and new watch behind. When Jeremy did not return that night, Diane called the police. At first, authorities believed that Jeremy had run away to join the fair. However, no evidence was found to support this theory; his family and friends did not believe that he would run away.
On Sunday, August 17th, the fair left town, and ominous rumors began to swirl about Jeremy's disappearance. During the week of the fair, several parties were held. According to one rumor, Jeremy attended one of these parties and was offered a beer that was laced with a powerful, illegal drug. One investigator was able to find witnesses that placed Jeremy at two parties that week, and it is possible that he died accidentally from an overdose at one of these parties. It was also possible that Jeremy had a heart murmur which caused his death.
An anonymous jail source told police an even more disturbing story. He claimed that three local teenagers showed up and harassed Jeremy and a few of his friends while they were swimming in a local lake. One of the teenagers apparently had a gun and began shooting at Jeremy for "target practice". According to the source, Jeremy was then shot and seriously wounded. The teenagers took Jeremy to a local cabin in an attempt to nurse him back to help. However, he later died from his wounds, according to the source. Then, the teenagers allegedly buried Jeremy's body in the woods near the cabin. Authorities searched the area surrounding the cabin, but found nothing.
Then, authorities talked to Cecilia Fish, a sister of Jeremy's friend Johnny. She said that on the day after Jeremy vanished, between midnight and 1 am, she and a friend were leaving her sister's apartment when they ran into a neighborhood teen with blood all over his clothes. Shocked, they asked what happened, and the man responded "This happened hours ago". The man laughed and then went into another apartment.
A half hour later, Johnny arrived at his other sister's apartment; he was shaking and terrified of something, but refused to say what had happened.
After three months of inactivity, the Coos County Sheriff's Department was finally contacted and asked to assist in the search for his whereabouts. However, to this day, he has not been found.
Suspects: No names have been revealed in this case, although three to four individuals from the Myrtle Point area have been considered suspects. Their names have reportedly come up in several rumors surrounding Jeremy's disappearance. The person on the top of the suspect list was later arrested and given a life sentence for an unrelated murder.
Extra Notes: This case first aired on the January 18, 1989 episode.
There are some discrepancies with the timeline for the week that Jeremy vanished. The broadcast state that Jeremy was last seen on Friday, August 15th. Other sources state that Jeremy actually vanished on Thursday, August 14th.

Terry steinhoff1

Terry Steinhoff

Results: Unsolved. Several people who were believed to have information on Jeremy's fate have since died. His former baby sitter, Terry Steinhoff, died of a drug overdose in prison in 2007 while serving time for the unrelated murder of a Coos Bay woman. Around 1988, four of Jeremy's friends died together in a car accident, and his friend, Johnny, died in January 2011.
His stepfather, Orville Gulseth, died in 2003 at age 66. Jeremy's maternal grandmother died in December of 1988. His father, Joe Flaherty, died in December 2008.
Police consider Terry Steinhoff and his cousin David persons of interest in the case. According to some accounts, Jeremy was last seen alive sitting in a vehicle with Terry. David was the man seen covered in blood shortly after Jeremy's disappearance. Before his death, police tried to interview Terry about the case, but he was not forthcoming. Investigators searched property owned by the Steinhoffs, but found no trace of Jeremy. Jeremy's mother thinks his remains are located somewhere in Coos County.
His family believes he's deceased, and they held a memorial service for him in August 2011 on the twenty-fifth anniversary of his disappearance.