Real Name: Fred Gardner
Case: Lost Loved One
Location: Monticello, New York
Details: In 1961, Fred Gardner of Grand Rapids, Michigan, vanished after separating from his wife. He left behind a young son and daughter. Then, in 1988, William Fenshaw of Monticello, New York, also vanished, after leaving three daughters and a son. In 1990, it was determined that Fred Gardner and William Fenshaw were the same person, and now, his six children want to be reunited with him.
Extra Notes: The case was featured as a part of the November 20, 1991 episode.
Results: Solved. In 1992, Fred Gardner, also known as William Fenshaw, returned home to his children and was reunited with them all. Sadly he passed away in 1994. He was surrounded by all of his children.