Real Name: Ethel Kidd
Nicknames: No known nicknames
Location: Burr Hill, Virginia
Date: April 12, 1989
Details: Ethel had moved to Burr Hill, Virginia, 70 miles from Washington, DC. She and her husband, Gilbert, bought a parcel of land in 1988 and built a home for their retirement. Their children and grandchildren lived nearby. This was very important to her, since her life centered around her loving family. On Wednesday, April 12th, 1989, construction on the new house was almost finished. Ethel was spending a great deal of time there, and on that morning, she had visited her daughter, who lived about a mile from there. She returned home about 2pm and was seen picking up her mail from the street side mailbox. The next morning, her daughter called her at 7:30am, but she didn't answer. Instead, her answering machine picked up. She assumed that she was on her way over for a morning cup of coffee, but she never showed up. Two hours later, at 9:30am, her son-in-law, Thomas (either his real name or not), drove by her house, only to find her car still parked in the driveway. As he approached the house, he found a road atlas laying in the yard. Investigators later found motel stationary that contained writings of a sexual nature inside it. These had been used by the suspect as flash cards along the highway to solicit sex from other drivers. There was also an outline for the perpetrator to follow in his plan of murder, including references to selecting a location and then obtaining a new identity.
Without noticing these items inside the atlas, Thomas entered her house, finding the front door unlocked. That was very unusual, as she always kept her doors locked. But nothing inside was out of place. It did not appear that there had been a robbery or any signs of a struggle. Right away, a large search party formed to begin looking for her. They searched the acres of fields and woods surrounding the area where she lived, but found no clues or any sign of her. Eight days later, a hunter was in the woods only three miles from her house. He came upon a most disturbing sight. Even though this area had been thoroughly searched the previous week, there was her murdered body, bound to a tree and facing a logging road only 50 feet away. She had been raped, strangled, and dead for about seven days. Due to the lack of decomposition, authorities believed that her body had been stored in some kind of a refrigeration unit such as a refrigerated semi truck or a walk-in freezer. The cord used to bind her was only used in hotel and hospital draperies and not available to the public.
Suspects: Police found a folded up map at the scene to suggest that Ethel's killer had stopped to ask for directions. Another piece of evidence found was the paper left by the killer which was a "list" for murder. Police believe the killer was a white male in his 30s or 40s, but have no suspects.
Extra Notes: This case first aired on the October 2, 1991 episode.
Results: Solved. A subsequent airing of this case on the show generated a tip about a suspect named Edward Wayne Beverly, who was serving time in prison for an unrelated crime. Although his name was not mentioned in the broadcast at the time, another update featuring Keely Shaye Smith indicated that he was recognized by the handwriting on his preparation list found within the atlas he left at the scene. He had lived in Burr Hill, Virginia, but he suddenly left the area after the murder. Once he was tracked down to a Tennesse prison, DNA and fingerprint matches were confirmed. A few months before he was to be released from prison, He was convicted of Ethel's murder. He died there in Late 2008. Sadly, Ethel's widower, Gilbert, passed away in 2006 at the age of 71.